Robert Benton Director Dustin Hoffman Dutch Schultz Actor Nicole Kidman Drew Preston Actor Loren Dean Billy Bathgate Actor Bruce Willis Bo Weinberg Actor Steven Hill Otto Berman Actor Steve Buscemi Irving Actor Billy Jaye Mickey Actor John Costelloe Lulu Actor Timothy Jerome Dixie Davis Actor Stanley Tucci Lucky Luciano Actor Mike Starr Julie Martin Actor Robert F. Colesberry Jack Kelly Actor, Producer Stephen Joyce Mr. Hines Actor Frances Conroy Mary Behan Actor Moira Kelly Becky Actor Kevin Corrigan Arnold Actor Tom Stoppard Screenwriter Arlene Donovan Producer Néstor Almendros Cinematographer Alan Heim Film Editing David Ray Film Editing Robert M. Reitano Film Editing Mark Isham Original Music Patrizia von Brandenstein Production Design Dennis Bradford Art Director Tim Galvin Art Director George DeTitta Sr. Set Decoration Joseph G. Aulisi Costume Design Howard Feuer Casting