Mary Poppins Returns
Log in with Facebook
Forgot your password?
Don't have an account? Sign up here
and the Terms and Policies,
and to receive email from Rotten Tomatoes and Fandango.
Already have an account? Log in here
Please enter your email address and we will email you a new password.
No consensus yet.
No consensus yet.
All Critics (37)
| Top Critics (10)
| Fresh (29)
| Rotten (8)
| DVD (1)
Breillat has produced her funniest and most immediately pleasurable film to date.
A simple device, the parallel structure freshens and enlarges the familiar story precisely because Breillat doesn't put too much weight on it.
Those looking for a re-interpretation of a classic fairytale will certainly find it in Bluebeard. They just won't find a very good one.
A movie that has all the when-will-he-draw-the-scimitar suspense of Friday the 13th as made by Robert Bresson. In other words, none at all.
All fairy tales have morals and the one in Ms. Breillat's Bluebeard is brutal, suitably bloody and, like all good retellings, both similar to and different from earlier iterations.
Bluebeard revisits themes often found in Breillat's films -- sibling rivalry, pedophilia, gender conflict -- but it remains fresh and new.
I'm starting to think that even mediocre contemporary French films, with their myriad question marks, outstrip most American fare -- and Catherine Breillat's Bluebeard is hardly mediocre, though it is modest in scale.
Breillat's ideas owes much to Angela Carter, yet The Bloody Chamber author would surely be depressed by the lack of dynamism on display.
Murky and cold, this retelling of the fairy tale has an effectively grim tone that cleverly plays with our expectations while examining some provocative themes. But it's not very engaging.
Catherine Breillat's move from arthouse provocations to ponderous period dramas continues with this austere, slyly experimental adaptation of Charles Perrault's grisly classic.
While it contains more layers than a slab of Viennetta, this might actually be Breillat's most accessible film to date. Just don't expect anyone to live happily ever after.
It's a playful approach, but Breillat's flat visual style and the deliberately stiff and austere performances she gets from her actors make this more of a chore than it should be.
In "Bluebeard," two young girls, Catherine(Marilou Lopes-Benites) and Marie-Anne(Lola Giovannetti), wander into an attic that they have not been strictly forbidden from entering but not exactly given permission to enter, either. There, they play games and read the story of Bluebeard again.
Marie-Catherine(Lola Creton) and Anne(Daphne Baiwir) are sent home from a private school when their father is killed by a carriage while saving a child. Things are no better at home when all of their belongings are taken away and their mother(Isabelle Lapouge) is left with two daughters she cannot a provide a dowry for. However, Bluebeard(Dominique Thomas), the enormously wealthy lord of a nearby castle, is looking for a new wife since all of his old ones have gone missing.
I don't recall specifically how much Catherine Breillat might have changed in adapting the classic fairytale for the screen but regardless she makes it her own. While much more sedate than most of her other movies, it has more than its share of transgressions and forbidden knowledge with her contributing much intelligent thought on the subject of female sexuality.(For this reason and I may be alone on this, I think Catherine Breillat would make a fine director for the next "Twilight" movie.) The girls in the present have their own weird ideas on what marriage is supposed to be and no idea what to expect in the future. On the other hand, Marie-Catherine has no illusions when it comes to marriage and Bluebeard and prepares herself accordingly.
A strangely disjointed tale, based on the Bluebeard fairy tale, told as a cautionary tale that leaves the viewer feeling somehow short-changed. One questions the artistic decision to tell the tale as a young girl reading it to her older sister, and then dissolving to the action of the story. The scenery is sumptuous, the costumes are gorgeous, the actors well chosen, but at a mere hour and twenty minutes, the ending seems forced, terribly rushed, and serves no other purpose than to allow the director to say she filmed an ending. The context is somehow missing, at least for this viewer. My favorite Muse calls this Breillat's most accessible film to date, and with that one must concur, but that still isn't saying much. One always comes away with the feeling that one missed something, some cultural reference or some mistranslated line of dialog, that would make the screenplay make more sense. This viewer has been left wanting a clearer message far too many times.
An aristocrat with a blue beard marries young girls, who always wind up dead. There are a few startling images near the end that pop out because the rest of the story so flat, but the for the most part the matter-of-fact minimalist style fades the magic and mystery of the fairy tale.
I really like the little girl reading the story, could have done with out the community theateresque medieval costumes.
There are no approved quotes yet for this movie.