Greg Berlanti Director, Writer Timothy Olyphant Dennis Actor Andrew Keegan Kevin Actor John Mahoney Jack Actor Dean Cain Cole Actor Matt McGrath Howie Actor Zach Braff Benji Actor Ben Weber Patrick Actor Billy Porter Taylor Actor Justin Theroux Marshall Actor Mary McCormack Anne Actor Nia Long Leslie Actor Robert Arce Purple Guy Actor Michael Bergin Kip Rogers Actor Connie Dolphin Line Producer Sam Irvin Co-Producer Mickey Liddell Producer Joseph Middleton Producer, Casting Julie Plec Co-Producer Christophe Beck Original Music Paul Elliott Cinematographer Todd Busch Film Editing Michelle Morris Casting Charles Daboub Jr. Production Design Mark Macauley Set Decoration Mas Kondo Costume Design Brian Hennessy First Assistant Director Mitch Kelleher Second Assistant Director Paula Fairfield Sound Supervisor Carla Murray Sound Designer, Sound Effects Editor Julianne Kelley Music Supervisor William Munroe Boom Operator