Leslie Hope Director Hilarie Burton Katherine Actor Tyler Hilton Caleb Actor Markie Post Lilly Actor Ed Asner Papa Noel Actor Randy Travis Mr. Greenhall Actor Brody Rose Zack Actor Ariana Neal Sienna Actor Dana Gourrier Janelle Actor Marcy Holland Screenwriter Brian D. Young Screenwriter Kenneth M. Badish Producer, Executive Producer Daniel Lewis Producer, Executive Producer Don E. Fauntleroy Cinematographer Andrew Cohen Film Editing C.C. Adcock Original Music Jayme Bohn Production Design, Costume Design Rikki Longanecker Set Decoration Sally Smith Costume Design Dean E. Fronk Casting Donald Paul Pemrick Casting