Christopher Shawn Shaw Director, Producer Thor Ramsey Guy Sides Actor, Screenwriter, Producer Joey Fatone Tino Actor Stephen Baldwin Chad Chase Actor, Producer Erin Cahill Carla Finney Actor Michael Monks Pastor Skip Finney Actor Donald Faison Jonathan Actor Andriana Manfredi Gretchen Actor Clancy McCartney Blaise Actor Isabella Hofmann Sue Actor William Baldwin Actor Bob Sáenz Screenwriter Wes Halula Screenwriter Andrea Kaufman Producer John McGalliard Producer Mike Lindell Executive Producer Beverley Mitchell Executive Producer Bo Hakala Cinematographer Alexis Evelyn Film Editing Michael Schultz Film Editing Karen Harper Production Design Rome Brooks Art Director Cami Nemanich Costume Design