Bill Duke Director Lou Diamond Phillips Monsignor Renzulli Actor Aaron Tveit Tommy Reilly Actor Gregory Alan Williams Judge Watford Actor Edy Ganem Alejandra Batista Actor Lauren Compton Nicki Actor Yohance Myles Willis Silk Thompkins Actor Mikki Val Betty Actor Camryn Jones Samantha Actor John Newberg Kent Dunbar Actor Susan LaBrecque Dr. Sylvia Touran Actor Ned Bowman Screenwriter Joyce Renee Lewis Screenwriter Michael Ricigliano Screenwriter Roger A. Brown Executive Producer Thada Catalon Producer Karlas Powell Producer Kurt Farquhar Original Music Steven Parker Cinematographer Cari Coughlin Film Editing Natasha Ward Casting Claire Sanchez Production Design Cydney Tucker Set Decoration Kim Martínez Costume Design