Laura Murphy Director Harvey Guillén Andy Actor Will Arnett Shamrock Actor Nicole Byer Mikayla Actor Jessica Lowe Erica Greenspan Actor Andrew Caldwell Josh Actor Joey Fatone Joey Fatone Actor James Austin Johnson Jeremy Fischbein Actor Nikki Glaser Phoebe Schluss Actor Nicole Richie Lizzie Lennox Actor Ken Marino Nikki Evans Actor Rob Riggle Mr. Knight Actor Aaron Eisenberg Writer Will Eisenberg Writer Luke Kelly-Clyne Producer