L.P. Director Nasim Pedrad Wesley Actor Robbie Amell Jared Actor Heather Graham Ángel de la Paz Actor Anna Camp Brooke Actor Lamorne Morris Sean Actor Sarah Burns Kaylie Actor Jessica Chaffin Debbie Actor Izzy Diaz Quantino Actor Mo Gaffney Principal Judy Actor Bryan Safi Goatee Actor George Basil Doug Actor Ellen Rapoport Screenwriter Nathan Kahane Producer Erin Westerman Producer Kelli Konop Producer Mason Novick Producer John Finemore Producer Elizabeth Grave Producer James Hoppe Executive Producer Jennifer Roth Executive Producer John Powers Middleton Executive Producer Tim Orr Cinematographer Mateo Messina Original Music Rachel Myers Production Design Vanessa Bryant Set Decoration Maximiliano Patko Costume Design