Bryan Spicer Director Tim Allen Brad Sexton Actor Kirstie Alley Caroline Sexton Actor Jay O. Sanders Samuel Yoder Actor Michael Lerner Phil Kleinman Actor Wayne Knight Bob Lachman Actor Larry Miller Inspector Derek Lester Actor Miguel A. Núñez Jr. Frank Hall, IRS Actor Megan Cavanagh Levinia Yoder Actor John Pyper-Ferguson Henner Lapp Actor Carrie Preston Rebecca Yoder Actor Ethan Phillips Jerry Actor John Caponera Dave Actor Katie Moore Anna Yoder Actor Bobby Steggert Samuel Jr. Actor Michael Angarano Sammy Yoder Actor Rosemary Knower Grandma Yoder Actor David Harscheid Grandpa Yoder Actor Hunter Stover Baby Yoder Actor Scout Stover Baby Yoder Actor June Claman Judge Joan Northcott Actor Marla Maples Cynthia Actor Holly Rudkin Mary Actor Crystal Bock Penny, Brad's secretary Actor Monica Deeter Hannah Yoder Actor Richard Pelzman Jonathan Yoder Actor Madeline Mager Sarah Actor Terrence Currier Elder Joseph Actor Hal Henderson Elder Thomas Actor Michael Howell Bailiff Actor Johanna Cox Emma Yoder Actor Stefan Aleksander Jacob Yoder Actor Holly Atkinson Teller Actor Emily Chamberlain Evelyn, Phil's secretary Actor Anthony Azizi Malik the Cabbie Actor David Maples IRS Agent Actor Markus Flanagan George Actor Wes Johnson Tourist Actor Rick Foucheux Tom Actor Drenda Spohnholtz Waitress Actor Marla Sucharetza Stacy Actor Jana Howington Writer Steve LuKanic Writer Richard Baker Executive Producer Bruce Economou Co-Producer Gayle Fraser-Baigelman Executive Producer Michael S. Glick Co-Producer Rick Messina Executive Producer Jonathan Sheinberg Producer Sid Sheinberg Producer Randy Edelman Original Music Buzz Feitshans IV Cinematographer Russell Denove Film Editing Victoria Burrows Casting Stephen Hendrickson Production Design Bob Shaw Art Director