Meredith Alloway Director, Screenwriter Lili Reinhart Apple Actor Lola Tung Pumpkin Actor Victoria Pedretti Cherry Actor Alexandra Shipp Fig Actor Emma Frances Chamberlain Pickle Actor Gabrielle Union Sharon Actor David Pinard Cookie Shop Guy Actor R Austin Ball Johnny Montgomery Actor Jeff Sinasac Diner Actor Charlie Henry Larsen Ashton Actor Lily Houghton Screenwriter Mason Novick Producer Diablo Cody Producer Trent Hubbard Producer Mary Anne Waterhouse Producer Katherine Romans Executive Producer Charlie Traisman Executive Producer Casey Durant Executive Producer Rachel Douglas Executive Producer