Jay Gammill Director, Producer, Film Editing Jess Weixler Jillian Actor Halley Feiffer Nancy Actor Jesse Eisenberg Tex Actor Jason Ritter Wally Actor Tippi Hedren Betty Actor Keir O'Donnell Danny Actor Jocelin Donahue Paula Actor Whitney Able Dana Actor Eben Kostbar Matthew Actor, Producer Jordan Davis Peter Actor James Duval Antonio Actor Matt Walsh Mr. Hightower Actor Craig Gellis Steel Actor Jim Beggarly Screenwriter, Producer Cory Knauf Producer Mark Gould Executive Producer Kevin Iwashina Executive Producer Eric Allan Kramer Executive Producer John Madden Executive Producer, Casting Eric Elbogen Original Music Reed Morano Cinematographer Franklin Peterson Film Editing Jeffrey Givens Production Design Julie Ziah Art Director Alisha Silverstein Costume Design