Rich Newey Director Kim Matula Katherine Actor Ian Harding Peter Actor Beth Leavel Susan Kraine Actor Lori Tan Chinn Arlene Actor Reginald VelJohnson Roy Actor Kathleen Garrett Mrs. Winchester Actor Leo James Davis Middle Peter Actor Kate MacCluggage Lily Baron Actor Blair Baker Charlie Actor Sara McDermott Ghost Actor Jack Carter Barton Teen Peter Actor Juan Carlos Infante Gabe Actor Estavion White Reporter Actor Christopher Innvar Robert Baron Actor Anna Clare Kerr Mother (1956) Actor Austin Schoenfeld Devon Actor Christopher Riley Young Peter Actor Annika Marks Screenwriter Keith Hemstreet Screenwriter Zac Hug Screenwriter Andrew Gernhard Producer Colin Theys Producer Ryan M. Murphy Executive Producer Branden James Maxham Cinematographer Bryan Capri Film Editing Anne-Kathrin Dern Original Music Donna J. Hattin Production Design Tim Swope Art Director Antuan Been Set Decoration Patricia McCorkle Casting Daniella Newton Casting Rebecca Weiss Casting