Sep 22, 2013
Oh, Bill Murray, I understand your pain, as I'd imagine it would be mighty easy to get lost in someone trying to interact with you when Scarlett Johansson's in room. Hm, let's see, he got a big comeback, scored a considerable sum of money, an Oscar nomination and a Golden Globe win, and got a vacation to Tokyo with one of the more beautiful women on the planet, so I'm kind of lost as to what Murray has lost with this deal. Maybe it was his soul or something, which would explain why he's been looking really, really old ever since this film (Hollywood doesn't age like this, Bill), and why he had to work with Sofia Coppola to be in this film. Hey, Francis Ford Coppola had to practically sell his soul to make "The Godfather Part III" and he ended up stuck with his daughter, and we all suffered because of it. Oh well, it was still an awesome film... to me, at least, and besides, it would appear as though little Sofia finally found her place in showbidnuss, or at least that's what we thought when this film first came out. No, Coppola has had a decent directorial career since 2003 I suppose, but I think she lost something in translation when we gave her an opening to do whatever she wanted to after this film. Oh well, at least we still have this film to keep us going, and yet, quite frankly, even in 2003, I wouldn't have given Coppola the OK to do whatever, because she makes more than a few decisions with this film that are kind of questionable.
It's something of a fad to intentionally underdevelop the focuses of a character study when they're ordinary folks, and while an aging actor and the unusually hot wife of a photographer are certainly more interesting than the usual bums films of this type meditate on, some ambiguities is nice, but not to this degree, as immediate development is borderline nonexistent, and gradual exposition is mighty lacking, which is a problem, largely because these are unique characters who are focused on pretty thoroughly to have only so much flesh-out, and partly because this film wastes too much time on dragging. At just barely over 100 minutes, this is a relatively brief affair, but, like I said, expository depth is pretty lacking, so in order to break even, this film spends long, long stretches of time presenting, not excess material, but excess filler, which drags on and on until repetitious ensues, then devolves into an aimlessness that challenges your attention, and whose blandness goes exacerbated by atmospheric limpness. This is one of your livelier Sofia Coppola films I suppose, and yet, the director isn't exactly known for keeping consistent with liveliness, so on top of being underdeveloped and overdrawn, this film further challenges engagement value with a rather cold atmosphere, anchored by dry quietness that typically blands things up and often goes so far as to dull things down. A testament to Coppola's competence as a filmmaker is this film's taking so many heavy blows and ultimately standing as rewarding, regardless of its shortcomings, but make no mistake, there are plenty of shortcomings in development and pacing, and they drag things out and down, challenging your investment, which should be kind of loose to begin with, considering natural shortcomings. This is certainly a meaty little drama, as it takes on plenty of storytelling issues and still stands as quite compelling at the end of the day, but the story that is so problematically told is kind of thin, at least in a sense of consequence, being not too much more than a study on a slice of life, only with a little less development and a little more limpness. The film doesn't go a whole lot of places, and that's a crying shame, because this film could have perhaps gone far, considering that it rewards in spite of storytelling shortcomings' emphasis on natural shortcomings, yet as things stand, natural shortcomings remain prominent, and go stressed enough through characterization and pacing problems for the final product to run the risk of being, if you will, "lost in underwhelmingness". Of course, when it's all said and done, while reward value isn't too firmly secured, it surprisingly still stands, compelling you through and through, and even catching your eyes, maybe even your ears, along the way.
As quiet as this film is, its soundtrack has become pretty popular, and really, I can't say that I'm blind as to why, because even though the pretty contemporary, relatively obscure songs that are found here and there throughout this film are hit-or-miss, and never hit too hard by their own musical right, some are decent, or at least fitting, livening up the film a bit, though not as much as an original score by Kevin Shields, whose melodic and rather soulful plays with subtle electronica is not only unique, but breathes yet more life into this very modern, very genuine character drama. This is a film driven by a lot of quietness, yet its musical ironically defines its heart, while proving to be attractive more often than not, as surely as Lance Acord's cinematography proves to be consistently attractive, with soft, yet striking color and occasionally rather dreamlike lighting that is always good-looking, but particularly stunning when it accentuates Scarlett Johansson... oh, and, uh, the lively Tokyo locations that this almost environmental character study relies a lot on. I don't know if the film is necessarily a stylistic marvel, but the aesthetic value of the film is relatively outstanding, perhaps even immersive, drawing you into the heart of a drama that, in order to compensate for shortcomings, is going to need worthwhile substance. Like I said, there's something kind of thin about the meat of this character drama, and there is certainly plenty of thinness in this story's underdeveloped and overdrawn execution, but this is still a very genuine, fairly intriguing story concept, with worthy thematic depth and wit that wouldn't be sold as surely as it ultimately is without Sofia Coppola's efforts, at least as the writer of a script that offers sharp dialogue and humor, as well as quite a bit of juice within what characterization there is, further soaked up by a directorial meditativeness that may get to be too limp for its own good, but generally proves to be effective in drawing the subtle depths of this character study. The strengths in storytelling are perhaps more subtle than the flaws, but those subtle touches go a long way in producing a tasteful, if flawed character study that charms, moves and endears thoroughly, yet still runs the risk of collapse into underwhelmingness, from which it is ultimately pried by the onscreen talents. Sure, material is limited for this colorful cast, but most everyone delivers, though not as much as the leads, who really do about as much as anyone or anything in saving the character drama as compelling, with the charismatic Bill Murray being effective as a beloved talent who begins to question the credibility of his career, while the startlingly beautiful Scarlett Johansson, nearing the end of her 17th year (17... Now I feel awkwa-nah, I can't even lie, she was already hot), remarkably convinces as a soft-spoken, but hearty woman who begins to question the path she has taken thus far in adulthood. Of course, it's the chemistry between Murray and Johansson that really drives this film, because as if the charisma between the leads isn't endearing enough, the convincingness of their relationship sells much of the core of this study on two people just trying to get by, and that convincingness is ultimately enough to nudge this film over into thorough compellingness, challenged by storytelling and natural shortcomings, but ultimately firmly secured by rewarding inspiration.
When it's all said, translated and done, underwhelmingness stands as a serious risk, due to serious limitations of expository depth, long stretches of aimless filler, - made all the more glaring by near-dulling atmospheric dryness - and natural limitations in dramatic weight, but through a lively soundtrack, lovely visuals and an endearing story concept, - brought to life by a clever script and thoughtful directorial performance, and truly sold by electric charisma and chemistry between Bill Murray and Scarlett Johansson - "Lost in Translation" stands as a thoroughly charming and generally quite compelling character study.
3/5 - Good
Verified