Jeff Bleckner Director Lauren Ambrose Leah Lever Actor Adam Kaufman Jake Lever Actor Susie Essman Malka Actor Ricki Lake Rabbi Gerry Actor Mercedes Ruehl Janice Lever Actor Natasha Lyonne Esther Actor Christy Pusz Carol Actor Harris Yulin Rabbi Belsky Actor Tonye Patano Emily Actor Donnie Keshawarz Raj Actor Sylvia Kauders Widow Goldfarb Actor Jayne Houdyshell Mrs. Finkelman Actor David Rossmer Rabbi Benjamin Lever Actor Jessalyn Wanlim Sales Clerk Actor Tibor Feldman Dr. Saloway Actor Jolly Abraham Priya Actor Jonathan C. Kaplan Feldman Actor Zachary Knower Carmie Actor Matt Walton Carter Actor Marc Wolf Art Actor Timothée Chalamet Young Jake Actor Sam Guncler Bentsi Actor Bess Rous Rifka Actor Natalie Knepp Female Guard Actor Welker White Instructor Actor Don Guillory Salesman Actor Jo Yang Nurse 2 Actor Aaron Lohr John Actor Kathleen Doyle Female Patient Actor Paul Geier Judge 1 Actor Pnenah Goldstein Screenwriter Brent Shields Executive Producer Michael Besman Executive Producer Charles Minsky Cinematographer Geoffrey Rowland Film Editing Jeff Beal Original Music Andrew Jackness Production Design James Feng Art Director Susan Ogu Set Decoration Stephanie Maslansky Costume Design Lynn Kressel Casting