Ted Koland Director, Screenwriter Justin Long Scott Actor Tyler Labine Lumpy Actor Jess Weixler Kristin Actor Addison Timlin Ramsey Actor Frances O'Connor Jaime Actor Shelley Long Gail Actor Evan Jones Winston Actor Michael Landes Priest Actor Peter Syvertsen Roger Actor David Abbitt Producer Jen Roskind Producer Sharyn Whiterabbit Steele Producer Chris Colbert Executive Producer Jeff Donald Executive Producer Scott Hill Executive Producer John Hood Executive Producer Seamus Tierney Cinematographer Grant Myers Film Editing Mateo Messina Original Music Jade Healy Production Design Britni West Set Decoration Kiersten Hargroder Costume Design Lynn Blumenthal Casting Mary Tricia Wood Casting