Robert Allan Ackerman Director Valerie Bertinelli SBI Agent Megan O'Malley Actor Harry Hamlin Chief Mitch Holt Actor Karen Sillas Dr. Hannah Garrison Actor Martin Donovan Paul Garrison Actor David Marshall Grant Father Tom McCoy Actor Mariska Hargitay Paige Price Actor William Russ Sheriff Steiger Actor Colm Feore Deacon Albert Fletcher Actor Michael Cumpsty Dr. Garrett Wright Actor Tim DeKay Prof. Christopher Priest Actor Olivia Birkelund Karen Wright Actor Katie Volding Jesse Holt Actor Pruitt Taylor Vince Olie Swain Actor Jeffrey DeMunn SAC Bruce Di Palma Actor Clayton Taylor Josh Garrison Actor Lego Louis Noga Actor Colin Ferguson Todd Actor Toni Lynn Byrd Natalie Actor George Sullivan Marty Wilheim Actor Steven Anderson Coroner Actor Sandra Shotwell Helen Actor Jeff Olson Lt. Olson Actor Michelle Wilson Darlene Actor Rosalind Soulam ER Nurse Actor Dane Stevens Coach John Olson Actor Taylor Burningham Billy Holt Actor Richard Brams Producer, Executive Producer Michele Brustin Executive Producer