Sophie Kargman Director, Executive Producer, Screenwriter Kiersey Clemons Susie Actor, Executive Producer Alex Wolff Jesse Actor Jim Gaffigan Sheriff Loggins Actor Rachel Sennott Jillian Actor Ken Marino Edgar Cabot Actor Alex Moffat Hayden Powers Actor David Walton Deputy Graham Actor Isaac Powell Ray Garcia Actor Geoffrey Owens President Andrews Actor Jared Gilman Jed Actor Dolly Wells Actor William Day Frank Screenwriter Adam Mirels Producer Robert Mirels Producer David B. Newhouse Executive Producer Conor Murphy Cinematographer, Cinematographer Christine Park Film Editing, Film Editor Jon Natchez Original Music Adam Reamer Production Design Abraham Chan Art Director Madeline Rocco Set Decoration Samantha Hawkins Costume Design Joanna Levinger Casting Meredith Tucker Casting David Newhouse Executive Producer Jamie Fairweather Executive Producer