Peter Benson Tony Director, Actor Lacey Chabert Josie Actor, Screenwriter, Executive Producer Tyler Hynes Cooper Actor Gregory Harrison Pete Actor Jesse Moss Jeff Actor Teryl Rothery Kate Actor Cassidy Nugent Delilah Actor Glen Gordon Ben Gable-Wilder Actor Donna Benedicto Molly Actor Christine Chatelain Ellie Actor Nathan Witte Nathan Actor Daniel Bacon Victor Actor Benita Ha Water Client Actor Alistair Abell Mr. Cox Actor Jason Tremblay Aaron Actor Kevan Ohtsji Mr. Yates Actor Faith Wright Carol Actor Azriel Dalman Ben at 6 Actor Ava Tuttle Delilah at 2 Actor Jaxson Butterworth Ben at 3 Actor Jackson Herrington Ivan Actor Jonathan Prince Screenwriter, Executive Producer Michael Reisz Screenwriter Charles Cooper Producer Susie Belzberg Executive Producer Doran Chandler Executive Producer Bianca Versteeg Executive Producer Allen Lewis Executive Producer Denielle Jackson Executive Producer Geoffrey Dodd Executive Producer Eric Jarboe Executive Producer Amanda Phillips Atkins Executive Producer Amy Krell Executive Producer Vince Balzano Executive Producer Brad Krevoy Executive Producer Geoff Wallace Cinematographer Kelly Herron Film Editing Mark Boyko Production Design Grace Alvarez Art Director Josephine Delgiglio Costume Design Jackie Lind Casting