John Polson Director Jesse Bradford Ben Cronin Actor Erika Christensen Madison Bell Actor Shiri Appleby Amy Actor Kate Burton Carla Actor Clayne Crawford Josh Actor Jason Ritter Randy Actor Kia Goodwin Rene Actor Dan Hedaya Coach Simkins Actor Michael Higgins Mr. Tillman Actor Nick Sandow Detective John Zabel Actor Pamela Isaacs Mrs. Egan Actor James DeBello Dante Actor Phyllis Somerville Aunt Gretchen Actor Charles F. Bohl Writer Phillip Schneider Writer John Penotti Producer Allison Lyon Segan Producer Joseph Caracciolo Jr. Producer Fisher Stevens Executive Producer Tim Williams Executive Producer Giles Nuttgens Cinematographer Kalina Ivanov Production Design Sarah Flack Film Editing Arjun Bhasin Costume Design Louis Febre Original Music John Debney Original Music Mindy Marin Casting Amanda Harding Casting Donna E. Bloom Unit Production Manager Stephen Lee Davis First Assistant Director Frank White III Art Director Diana White Set Decoration