James Marsh Director, Writer Gael García Bernal Elvis Sandow Actor William Hurt Pastor David Sandow Actor Paul Dano Paul Sandow Actor Pell James Malerie Sandow Actor Laura Harring Twyla Sandow Actor Milo Addica Bruno Actor, Writer, Producer Derek Alvarado Scoot Actor Laura Clifton Murray Actor Jessica Schwartz Diane Actor Mohammad Ahmed Mr. Chopra Actor Brady Coleman Clown Actor Michele Harrington Church Member Actor James Wilson Producer Edward R. Pressman Executive Producer John Schmidt Executive Producer Sofia Sondervan Executive Producer Eigil Bryld Cinematographer Max Avery Lichtenstein Original Music Jinx Godfrey Film Editing Sharon Lornofsky Production Design Sally Nicolaou Hamilton Set Decoration Lee Hunsaker Costume Design Kerry Barden Casting Toni Cobb Brock Casting Suzanne Crowley Casting Billy Hopkins Casting