It may be my favorite, and the rating may go up, because I'm currently watching the second, and I'm not loving it as much. I'm honestly not really sure what to say, or why I like it. Beyond the fact that I love Elijah Wood, and the rest of the actors and their performances, I don't know what I like about this. The plot and cinematography are pretty good, the action is cool but it doesn't stand out to me because there wasn't a whole lot, and I like the fellowship and the characters in it, aside from the other two Hobbits. I think one reason is that it's almost three hours and I still liked it.