Norman Gregory McGuire Director, Screenwriter, Producer, Executive Producer Jesse James Rev. Johnny Jones Actor, Executive Producer Mariana Paola Vicente Rebecca Actor Juan Felipe Barrientos Potro Actor Sharon Garrison Mary O'Neal Actor Todd Jenkins Billy Actor Ben Loggins Burn Actor Burton Gilliam Pawn Broker's Dad Actor Tonetta Weaver Lady Churchgoer Actor JT Barnett Producer John Belew Producer Carolina Hernandez Producer Chad Littlepage Producer, Film Editing Dino May Producer Marshall Culp Executive Producer Vicente Moctezuma Executive Producer Ian Sharar Cinematographer Amin Emam Original Music Will Stegall Art Director