Eric Bilitch Director, Screenwriter Finn Wittrock Spencer Koll Actor, Screenwriter Emilie de Ravin Alice Actor Nancy Travis Mrs. Koll Actor Jessy Schram Emily Actor Jack Coleman Mr. Koll Actor Matt O'Leary Toad Actor Michael Beach Marc Actor Alphonso McAuley Paul Actor Deborah Del Prete Producer Jason Gurvitz Producer Monica Raymund Executive Producer John Styles Jr. Executive Producer Zack Eginton Cinematographer Benjamin Redmond Film Editing Harlan Silverman Original Music Lauren Meyer Production Design Katie Cape Set Decoration Katherine Hegarty Costume Design Deborah Aquila Casting