Shazam!
High Life
Widows
The Walking Dead
Log in with Facebook
OR
By creating an account, you agree to the Privacy Policy and the Terms and Policies, and to receive email from Rotten Tomatoes and Fandango.
Please enter your email address and we will email you a new password.
We want to hear what you have to say but need to verify your account. Just leave us a message here and we will work on getting you verified.
Please reference “Error Code 2121” when contacting customer service.
No consensus yet.
All Critics (27) | Top Critics (4) | Fresh (22) | Rotten (5) | DVD (1)
The material is simple and irresistible, and Sydney Pollack stages it well (though without transcending the essential superficiality of his talent). May 26, 2008 | Full Review…
The material is simple and irresistible, and Sydney Pollack stages it well (though without transcending the essential superficiality of his talent).
Dave Kehr
A sordid spectacle of hard times, a kind of existentialist allegory of life. May 26, 2008 | Full Review…
A sordid spectacle of hard times, a kind of existentialist allegory of life.
Variety Staff
The acting is strident and overblown, the narrative technique gimmicky and obvious, and the implication that the competitors' situation is a microcosm of a wider-reaching American malaise rather pretentious. Jun 24, 2006 | Full Review…
The acting is strident and overblown, the narrative technique gimmicky and obvious, and the implication that the competitors' situation is a microcosm of a wider-reaching American malaise rather pretentious.
The movie is by far the best thing that Pollack has ever directed (with the possible exception of The Scalphunters). May 20, 2003 | Rating: 4/5
The movie is by far the best thing that Pollack has ever directed (with the possible exception of The Scalphunters).
Vincent Canby
The film's problem is that it is almost an embittered celebration of exhaustion. Jul 12, 2018 | Full Review…
The film's problem is that it is almost an embittered celebration of exhaustion.
Penelope Houston
They Shoot Horses, Don't They? becomes not merely an incisive critique of the exploitation that celebrities are inclined to, but perhaps of capitalism itself. Sep 27, 2017 | Rating: 7/10 | Full Review…
They Shoot Horses, Don't They? becomes not merely an incisive critique of the exploitation that celebrities are inclined to, but perhaps of capitalism itself.
Kyle Turner
It's depressing as hell, so it's not a movie I would watch repeatedly, but I'm sure glad I saw it. This is an important film about a time in America's history that wasn't so glamorous. You won't forget it. Jun 17, 2013 | Rating: 3/4 | Full Review…
It's depressing as hell, so it's not a movie I would watch repeatedly, but I'm sure glad I saw it. This is an important film about a time in America's history that wasn't so glamorous. You won't forget it.
Austin Kennedy
There has never been a film quite so original as this, featuring a wealth of noted actors fighting for their lives in a dance competition taking place during the Great Depression. Aug 15, 2011 | Rating: 4/4 | Full Review…
There has never been a film quite so original as this, featuring a wealth of noted actors fighting for their lives in a dance competition taking place during the Great Depression.
Wesley Lovell
An allegorical, socially conscious response to the injustices of the Depression era. May 26, 2008 | Rating: 4/4 | Full Review…
An allegorical, socially conscious response to the injustices of the Depression era.
Pollack's adaptation of Horace McCoy's depression era novel has not dated well. May 26, 2008 | Full Review…
Pollack's adaptation of Horace McCoy's depression era novel has not dated well.
Film4 Staff
Grim but compelling tale set in a Depression era dance marathon. Gig Young deservedly copped the Oscar. Feb 17, 2008 | Rating: 5/5
Grim but compelling tale set in a Depression era dance marathon. Gig Young deservedly copped the Oscar.
Steve Crum
Sydney Pollack's screen version of the powerful Depression-era dance marathon is extremely well acted, particularly by Jane Fonda as the suicidal actress, her first great performance. Jan 4, 2007 | Rating: A- | Full Review…
Sydney Pollack's screen version of the powerful Depression-era dance marathon is extremely well acted, particularly by Jane Fonda as the suicidal actress, her first great performance.
Emanuel Levy
A dance hall requires poor drifters and lost Depression-era souls to keep dancing for prize money. This film shouldn't work: set almost entirely in one location with the main characters fatigued to the point of almost passing out, the film's pace could slow to a standstill, much like the "dancing" we see by the end of the film. But it does work, thanks to the fantastic performances by Jane Fonda and Michael Sarrazin. Gig Young adds some energy to the film as one of the few conscious characters. The film is about the Depression, but it's more about class issues. Watching poor people dance to their deaths, the rich are shown getting pleasure out of others' misery, benefitting from the society that deems them superior. Overall, with everything against it, They Shoot Horses, Don't They? nevertheless delivers.
Super Reviewer
extremely well acted but profoundly depressing
In Depression era down-and-out Los Angeles a dance marathon on Santa Monica pier affords the opportunity to look in on the various lives involved. Overdone, yes, okay, but still moving as the cast embraces the cut out characters presented. Sarrazin, York, et al deliver the goods, but the picture belongs to Henry's little girl who manages to do Daddy proud. Gig Young as the ringmaster is nothing short of phenomenal.
A mostly competently made, fascinatingly bleak tale concerning a dance marathon and how some very different characters are affected by its rigorous rules. This movie came so close to being a great, uncompromisingly grim look on the state of show-business, but it makes a deadly mistake at its conclusion, going a step over-the-top and opting to be poetic not naturally, but just for the sake of being so. Still, despite it taking a while to get into it, once you get adjusted to the pace it becomes enamoring. Jane Fonda couldn't be better, and she gets solid support from Michael Sarrazin as her on-again, off-again dance partner, Red Buttons as a likable sailor, and Susannah York who is a nervous breakdown waiting to happen. Sydney Pollack creates a dark atmosphere for his depressing picture, but doesn't quite bring it into classic/greatness territory, as evidenced by its melodramatic finale.
View All Quotes
View All