Claire Scanlon Director Ellie Kemper Kimmy Schmidt Actor Tituss Burgess Titus Andromedon Actor Jane Krakowski Jacqueline White Actor Carol Kane Lillian Kaushtupper , Fiona Actor Daniel Radcliffe Prince Frederick Actor Jon Hamm Richard Wayne Gary Wayne Actor Sara Chase Cyndee Pokorny Actor Lauren Adams Gretchen Chalker Actor Amy Sedaris Mimi Kanassis Actor Michael Carlsen Mikey Politano Actor Fred Armisen Robert Durst Actor Chris Parnell Junior Actor Jack McBrayer Sandy Parcell Actor Johnny Knoxville C.J. Actor Sol Miranda Donna Maria Nuñez Actor Dylan Gelula Xanthippe Voorhees Actor Heidi Gardner Jenny Actor Zak Orth Cody Santimonio Actor Patch Darragh Nick Actor Robert Carlock Screenwriter, Executive Producer Tina Fey Screenwriter, Executive Producer Sam Means Executive Producer David Miner Executive Producer Kerry Orent Producer John Inwood Cinematographer Kyle Gilman Film Editing Mylene Santos Art Director Matthew Hemesath Costume Design Cindy Tolan Casting