Gary Cole Sheriff Lucas Buck Actor Jake Weber Dr. Matt Crower Actor Paige Turco Gail Emory Actor Nick Searcy Deputy Ben Healy Actor Lucas Black Caleb Temple Actor Brenda Bakke Selena Coombs Actor Sarah Paulson Merlyn Temple Actor Sarah Lynn Moore Guest Star Danny Masterson Guest Star Chris Blackwelder Guest Star Kelly Mizell Guest Star Amy Steel Guest Star Deborah Winstead Guest Star Michael Mattison Guest Star Lanelle Markgraf Guest Star Randell Haynes Guest Star Victor Bumbalo Guest Star Sam Raimi Executive Producer Rob Tapert Executive Producer James Frawley Director