Jessica Lange Elsa Mars Actor Kathy Bates Ethel Darling Actor Sarah Paulson Bette & Dot Tattler Actor Michael Chiklis Dell Toledo Actor Angela Bassett Desiree Dupree Actor Evan Peters Jimmy Darling Actor Frances Conroy Gloria Mott Actor Emma Roberts Maggie Esmerelda Actor Denis O'Hare Stanley Actor Finn Wittrock Dandy Mott Actor Danny Huston Massimo Dolcefino Guest Star Celia Weston Lillian Hemmings Guest Star Neil Patrick Harris Chester Creb Guest Star Grace Gummer Penny Guest Star Angela Sarafyan Alice Guest Star Jamie Brewer Marjorie Guest Star Chrissy Metz Ima 'Barbara' Wiggles Guest Star John Cromwell Young Arden Guest Star Miles Doleac Watcher Guest Star Erika Ervin Amazon Eve Guest Star Mat Fraser Paul the Illustrated Seal Guest Star Michael Krikorian Cop Guest Star Shauna Rappold Lucy Creb Guest Star Rose Siggins Legless Suzi Guest Star Ryan Murphy Executive Producer Brad Falchuk Executive Producer Dante Di Loreto Executive Producer Tim Minear Executive Producer Jennifer Salt Executive Producer James Wong Executive Producer Bradley Buecker Executive Producer