Ivana Milicevic Anastasia , Carrie Hopewell Actor Antony Starr Lucas Hood Actor Ulrich Thomsen Kai Proctor Actor Frankie Faison Sugar Bates Actor Ben Cross Mr. Rabbit Actor Rus Blackwell Gordon Hopewell Actor Ryann Shane Deva Hopewell Actor Hoon Lee Job Guest Star Matt Servitto Deputy Brock Lotus Guest Star Demetrius Grosse Deputy Emmett Yawners Guest Star Trieste Kelly Dunn Deputy Siobhan Kelly Guest Star Daniel Ross Owens Mayor Dan Kendall Guest Star Lili Simmons Rebecca Bowman Guest Star Matthew Rauch Clay Burton Guest Star Derek Cecil Dean Xavier Guest Star Alan Ball Executive Producer Greg Yaitanes Executive Producer Peter Macdissi Executive Producer Miguel Sapochnik Director Jonathan Tropper Writer David Schickler Writer