Dennis McNicholas Creator Chris Parnell Narrator Jeffrey Wright Batman Voice Melissa Villaseñor Robin Voice Rosario Dawson Catwoman Voice Brent Spiner Joker Voice Bobby Moynihan Penguin Voice John Leguizamo Riddler Voice Heidi Gardner Harley Quinn, Miss Tuesday Voice Alan Tudyk Alfred Voice Kenan Thompson Commissioner Gordon Voice Jason Sudeikis Mayor Hill Voice Brooke Shields Vicki Vale Voice Seth Meyers Jack Ryder Voice Paul Scheer Mr. Charleyhorse Voice Fred Armisen King Scimitar Voice Tim Meadows Dr. Arkham Voice Ike Barinholtz Two-Face, Harvey Dent Voice Ray Wise Announcers Voice