Kimberly Caldwell Host Joe Capobianco Judge Sabina Kelley Judge Alexis Kovacs Contestant Jessica Rotwein Contestant Brittan "London" Reese Contestant Christina "Charlie" Petty Contestant Jon Mesa Contestant Kyle Giffen Contestant Meghan Pagliaroni Contestant Nicky Hennerez Contestant Roman Abrego Contestant Tiffany Perez Contestant Jonathan Murray Executive Producer Gil Goldschein Executive Producer Rico Martinez Executive Producer