John de Mol Creator Michelle Julianne Fernandes Costa Contestant Steven Daigle Contestant April Dowling Contestant Memphis Garrett Contestant Dan Gheesling Contestant Jessie Godderz Contestant Brian Hart Contestant Jerry Mac Donald Contestant Renny Martyn Contestant Bryan Ollie Contestant Keesha Smith Contestant Bunky Miller Guest Angie Swindell Contestant Libra Thomas Contestant Jun Song Guest Julie Chen Host Jase Wirey Guest Janelle Pierzina Guest Jen Johnson Guest Matt McDonald Guest Allison Grodner Executive Producer Rich Meehan Executive Producer Christopher Roach Executive Producer