Sullivan Stapleton Kurt Weller Actor Jaimie Alexander Jane Doe, Remi Actor Marianne Jean-Baptiste Bethany Mayfair Actor Rob Brown Edgar Reade Actor Audrey Esparza Tasha Zapata Actor Ashley Johnson Patterson Actor Ukweli Roach Dr. Borden Actor John Hodgman Guest Star Jordana Spiro Guest Star Erinn Ruth Guest Star Trieste Kelly Dunn Guest Star François Arnaud Guest Star Martin Gero Executive Producer Greg Berlanti Executive Producer Sarah Schechter Executive Producer Mark Pellington Executive Producer Marcos Siega Executive Producer