Ilana Glazer Ilana Wexler Creator, Actor, Executive Producer, Writer Abbi Jacobson Abbi Abrams Creator, Actor, Executive Producer, Writer Paul W. Downs Trey Pucker Guest Star Amy Ryan Oliver's Mother Guest Star Kimiko Glenn Cashier Guest Star Grayson Taylor Oliver Guest Star Leslie Meisel Pregnant Woman Guest Star Jimmy Palumbo Angry Guy Guest Star Eric Slovin Bartender Guest Star Karen Vicks Subway Woman Guest Star Amy Poehler Executive Producer Dave Becky Executive Producer Tony Hernandez Executive Producer Samantha Saifer Executive Producer Lucia Aniello Director