Josh Duhamel Host, Executive Producer Andrew Shayde Contestant Jacky "Shu" Shu Contestant Melissa Berglund Contestant Shengul "Shaggy" Plummer Contestant David "Sarge" Moore Contestant Elyse Rodriguez Contestant Ikeila "Kei" Smart Contestant Melvin Davis Contestant Bekah Telew Contestant Steven Mosier Contestant Summer Lynne Seasons Contestant Justin Palmer Contestant James Brian "Huddy" Hudson Contestant Yue Pun Szeto Contestant Lauren Cisneros Campbell Contestant Lourdes Spurlock Contestant Yolanda "Yoli" Stennett Contestant Erika "Devi" Deveney Shea Wall Contestant Erica Franzzo Contestant Anthony Franzzo Contestant Louis "Freddie" Meyers IV Contestant Rachel Johnston Contestant Stephen Craig Contestant Mike Ward Contestant Michael J. Luisi Executive Producer Julie Pizzi Executive Producer Rupert Dobson Executive Producer Jacob Lane Executive Producer Emer Harkin Executive Producer