Michael Weatherly Dr. Jason Bull Actor Freddy Rodríguez Benny Colón Actor Geneva Carr Marissa Morgan Actor Jaime Lee Kirchner Danny James Actor Annabelle Attanasio Cable McCrory Actor Chris Jackson Chunk Palmer Actor Brad Garrett Ron Getman Guest Star Cara Buono Amaya Andrews Guest Star Dereje Tarrant Caleb Houston Guest Star John Siciliano Harrison Guest Star Joe Holt Kellan King Guest Star Corey Allen Abel Bekele Guest Star Terrence Shingler Man in Suit Guest Star Adrienne D. Williams Judge Harper Guest Star Alina Cho Daytime Talk Show Host Guest Star Ben Thompson Jeff Hill Guest Star Jeff Williams Juror 10 Guest Star Holly Lisker Juror 5 Guest Star Shara Ashley Zeiger Juror 7 Guest Star Jake Soister Officer of the Court Guest Star Mirirai Sithole Naomi Guest Star Nnamudi Amobi Neighbor Guest Star Paul Attanasio Executive Producer Phil McGraw Executive Producer Jay McGraw Executive Producer Justin Falvey Executive Producer Darryl Frank Executive Producer Sarah H. Haught Writer Peter Werner Director