Michael Weatherly Dr. Jason Bull Actor Freddy Rodríguez Benny Colón Actor Geneva Carr Marissa Morgan Actor Jaime Lee Kirchner Danny James Actor Chris Jackson Chunk Palmer Actor MacKenzie Meehan Taylor Rentzel Actor Samantha Mathis Avery Kress Guest Star Demosthenes Chrysan Amir Elmasry Guest Star Montego Glover Astrid Montego Guest Star Griffin Santopietro James Donovan Guest Star Patricia Mauceri Fatima Elmasry Guest Star Michael McFadden Paul Martin Guest Star John B. McCann Juror 11, Harold Miller Guest Star David Oliver Juror 12 Guest Star Ashley Brooke Makayla Guest Star Denim Henry Guest Star Carolyn McCormick Judge Stadler Guest Star Alyssa Keegan Kim Donovan Guest Star Briana Swann Christie Juror 3 Guest Star Debra Wassum Juror 8 Guest Star Paul Attanasio Executive Producer Phil McGraw Executive Producer Jay McGraw Executive Producer Justin Falvey Executive Producer Darryl Frank Executive Producer Chamblee Smith Writer Anne Hamilton Director