Jun 15, 2018
Like the novel its based on, BBCs adaptation of The Cuckoos Calling isnt anything revolutionary, but it sure is a lot of fun. When it comes to this adaptation, the biggest thing worth talking about is Tom Burkes portrayal of Cormoran Strike, because its really the best aspect of the show. Thats not to say the show is bad or anything, on the contrary, its rather good, but Tom Burke is just the brightest part of the show. He is perfectly cast as Strike and his performance is just captivating to witness. He commands the screen with such utter ease, its honestly incredible. The really nice thing about his portrayal of Strike is that it feels a lot warmer than the Strike of the novels, but at the same time he still very much feels like hes playing the same character thats in the novels. Its just the way Burke delivers the lines and the way his charisma shines through the screen that makes him so enthralling in this show.
Holliday Grainger is similarly good as Robin Ellacott. Shes not given nearly as much to do in these three episodes as Burkes Strike is given, but she still manages to shine fairly brightly, too. Her chemistry with Strike is spot on, and she does wonders with giving Robin a third dimension that shes really not written with in this adaptation. (The novel spends a lot more time with Robin than the show does, and as such, the shows depiction of Robin is lacking. But Grainger does make up for that somewhat with her performance.) Unfortunately, her fiance, Matthew (Kerr Logan), is given even less to do, barely appearing in the three episodes that comprise this adaptation at all. Its a shame since their home life does play some importance in the subsequent books in the series, and Matthew has had a total of about one minute of screen time thus far. But, such is life.
As for the show itself, its really good. Like the book, it doesnt do anything particularly new or revolutionary with the genre, but its a very enjoyable and well put together mystery. If I had one complaint about the show, its that it doesnt really do anything interesting visually. It does nothing to differentiate itself visually from every other detective show currently being made, and its a shame since most detective shows right now arent about a one-legged ex-soldier whos now a private detective. The premise is at least unique and interesting, but the visuals dont offer anything that matches the uniqueness of the writing. That being said, its still very competently shot and directed, and often times very beautiful. Just nothing particularly unique.
The mystery itself is well put together, and its executed just as well as it is in the novel. Its not so easily solvable that everyone will have it figured out by the end of the first episode, but its not so ridiculous that nobody will have been able to figure it out by the end of the third episode. So, it definitely does its job. The visuals, and especially the soundtrack and sound effects, really do a good job of leading the audience through the mystery. Im particularly thinking of the climax of the story, about 2/3 of the way through the third episode, where the soundtrack really hammers home the tension thats been building throughout the episodes, all leading up to the moment where the murderer confesses, in true whodunnit style.
I dont have much to say about Strike: The Cuckoos Calling, good or bad, because, like the novel, theres just not a whole lot to say. Its an enjoyable mystery, filled with fairly well-written characters, that feels like a homage to old detective stories while also being distinctly modern. Its lots of fun, well written, well acted, and well directed. Theres nothing particularly challenging about it, but thats okay. Theres nothing particularly unique about how it looks, but thats okay, too. I do like that Strike is representative of the disabled community, thats nice, and I feel like hes a good representation for the community as his disability doesnt define his character at all. Hes a really good detective who just happens to be missing a leg. Overall, I really enjoyed Strike: The Cuckoos Calling, and Im looking forward to BBCs adaptation of The Silkworm (the second novel in the Cormoran Strike series), which starts airing next week.
Verified