Andie MacDowell Judge Olivia Lockhart Actor Dylan Neal Jack Griffith Actor Bruce Boxleitner Bob Beldon Actor Barbara Niven Peggy Beldon Actor Brennan Elliott Warren Saget Actor Teryl Rothery Grace Sherman Actor Sarah Smyth Justine Actor Paula Shaw Charlotte Jeffers Actor Corey Sevier Seth Gunderson Actor Timothy Webber Moon Actor Tom Stevens Eric Griffith Actor Sebastian Spence Cliff Harting Actor Jesse Hutch Luke Bailey Guest Star Roark Critchlow Dan Sherman Guest Star Leah Cairns Katie Guest Star David Orth Judge Andrews Guest Star Dan Wigutow Executive Producer Ron French Executive Producer Sue Tenney Executive Producer Andy Mikita Director Susin Nielsen Writer