Forest Whitaker Special Agent Sam Cooper Actor Janeane Garofalo Beth Griffith Actor Michael Kelly John "Prophet" Sims Actor Beau Garrett Gina LaSalle Actor Matt Ryan Mick Rawson Actor Kirsten Vangsness Penelope Garcia Actor Joseph McKelheer Unsub Guest Star David Marciano Det. Jim Brigman Guest Star Lisa Kay Jennings Jane Guest Star Demetrius Grosse Barry Vernon Guest Star Matt Gerald Det. Steve Craig Guest Star Jamie Renee Smith Cindy Guest Star Sydelle Noel Claire Vernon Guest Star Susan Angelo Coroner Guest Star Jayson Blair Mike Guest Star Tammy Dahlstrom Trish Guest Star Joanna Sotomura Lisa Guest Star Tad Coughenour Man Guest Star Steven Luna Todd Logan Guest Star Lois Atkins Joy Guest Star Tereza Rizzardi Mike's Mom Guest Star Chris Mundy Executive Producer Edward Allen Bernero Executive Producer Mark Gordon Executive Producer Deborah Spera Executive Producer Shintaro Shimosawa Director Stephen Cragg Writer