Jonny Lee Miller Eli Stone Actor Victor Garber Jordan Wethersby Actor Natasha Henstridge Taylor Wethersby Actor Loretta Devine Patti Actor Sam Jaeger Matt Dowd Actor James Saito Dr. Chen Actor Matt Letscher Nathan Stone Actor Julie Gonzalo Maggie Dekker Actor Tom Cavanagh Jeremy Stone Guest Star Laura Benanti Beth Keller Guest Star Jodi Long Judge Marcia Phelps Guest Star Pamela Reed Mrs. Stone Guest Star John Prosky Alan Cooke Guest Star Johnny Pacar Eli Age 19 Guest Star Megan Paul Young Beth Guest Star Tom Amandes Martin Posner Guest Star George Michael Himself Guest Star Phil Abrams Larry Conaver Guest Star Gokul Sherpa 1 Guest Star Barbara Niven Ellen Wethersby Guest Star Shawn Carter Peterson Jury Foreperson Guest Star Paul Ganus Hurried Man Guest Star Anthony Marciona Dancer Guest Star Greg Berlanti Writer Marc Guggenheim Writer Ken Olin Director