Daniel Sunjata Paul Briggs Actor Aaron Tveit Mike Warren Actor Vanessa Ferlito Catherine "Charlie" DeMarco Actor Brandon Jay McLaren Dale "DJ" Jakes Actor Manny Montana Joe "Johnny" Tuturro Actor Serinda Swan Paige Arkin Actor Gbenga Akinnagbe Jeremiah Bello Guest Star Jenn Proske Abby Guest Star Mia Kirshner Ashika Pearl Guest Star Sheaun McKinney Eddie Guest Star Avis-Marie Barnes Lieutenant Guest Star Jeff Eastin Executive Producer Sanford Bookstaver Director Daniel Shattuck Writer