Spencer Grammer Casey Cartwright Actor Jacob Zachar Rusty Cartwright Actor Clark Duke Dale Actor Scott Michael Foster Cappie Actor Paul James Calvin Owens Actor Jake McDorman Evan Chambers Actor Dilshad Vadsaria Rebecca Logan Actor Amber Stevens West Ashleigh Actor Johanna Braddy Jordan Reed Guest Star Nora Kirkpatrick Katherine Guest Star Olesya Rulin Abby Guest Star Aaron Hill The Beaver Guest Star Eileen Seton Betsy Guest Star Olivia Munn Lana Guest Star Dan Castellaneta Dr. Milton Hastings Guest Star Michael Lange Director Matt Whitney Writer