Donal Logue Sean Finnerty Actor Megyn Price Claudia Finnerty Actor Kevin Corrigan Eddie Finnerty Actor Lynsey Bartilson Lily Finnerty Actor Jake Burbage Henry Finnerty Actor Griffin Frazen Jimmy Finnerty Actor Richard Riehle Walt Finnerty Actor Miriam Flynn Sister Helen Guest Star Bret Harrison Brad O'Keefe Guest Star Eddie Karr Young Sean Guest Star Karri Bowman Faye Guest Star J.B. Gaynor Young Eddie Guest Star Dan Martin Mr. Pennix Guest Star Eric Kushnick Ice Cream Guy Guest Star Shannon Woodward Kristina Guest Star Sabrina Bertaccini Mrs. Delvecchio Guest Star Carol Kiernan Nun Guest Star Lee Arenberg Hair Plugs Guest Star Wesley Thompson David Guest Star Katy Selverstone Abby Guest Star Bill Martin Writer Tyrone Finch Writer Chris Kelly Writer Brad Copeland Writer Ned Goldreyer Writer David Israel Writer Tasha Goldstone Writer Aron Abrams Writer Gary Halvorson Director Tom Purcell Writer Mike Schiff Writer Paul Lazarus Director Bonnie Kallman Writer Jim O'Doherty Writer Gregory Thompson Writer Brian Levant Director Ken Kwapis Director John Blanchard Director Craig Zisk Director John Whitesell Director