Rutledge Wood Host Rob Anders Contestant Sung Kang Judge Anthony Anderson Judge Joel McHale Judge Terry Crews Judge Big E Judge Felix Arguelles Contestant Sheilah Spencir Contestant Jadejha Edwards Contestant Aldavid Jimerson Contestant Caroline Johnson Contestant "Jerzey" Jim Farell Contestant Kevin Lister Contestant Angela Arnold Contestant Arushi Garg Contestant Tim Warren Executive Producer Andy Thomas Executive Producer Sharon Levy Executive Producer DJ Nurre Executive Producer Michael Heyerman Executive Producer Rick Murray Executive Producer Chris Hale Executive Producer Fred Soulie Executive Producer Phil Breman Executive Producer