Matt Hicks Contestant Kelley Andrews Contestant Kimberly Birch Contestant Chelsea Brookshire Contestant Andrea Fox Contestant Carley Hawkins Contestant Anna Lisa Matias Contestant Rose Copeland Contestant Jacqueline Conroy Contestant Meghan Jones Contestant Karina Kennedy Contestant Leah Thom Contestant Maggie Toraason Contestant Danny Fenton Executive Producer Kevin Utton Executive Producer Matt Gould Executive Producer Ryan Seacrest Executive Producer Adam Sher Executive Producer Heather Schuster Executive Producer David Tibballs Executive Producer Rebecca Eisen Executive Producer