Dave Navarro Host Chris Nunez Judge Oliver Peck Judge Katherine "Tatu Baby" Flores Contestant E.S. Contestant "Mystical" Mike Paterek Contestant Jason Clay Dunn Contestant Madison "Maddie la Belle" Loftis Contestant Ally Lee Contestant Chris May Contestant James "Danger" Harvey Contestant Craig Foster Contestant Jime Litwalk Contestant Kyle Dunbar Contestant Joey "Hollywood" Hamilton Contestant Joshua Hibbard Contestant Richard "Made Rich" Parker Contestant Jackie Jennings Contestant Frank McManus Contestant Charlie Corwin Executive Producer Jay Peterson Executive Producer Andrea Richter Executive Producer