Dave Navarro Host Chris Nunez Judge Oliver Peck Judge David Bell Contestant Ashley Bennett Contestant "Gentle" Jay Blondel Contestant Lydia Bruno Contestant Damon Butler Contestant Keith Diffenderfer Contestant Kyle Dunbar Contestant Jim Francis Contestant Walter "Sausage" Frank Contestant Halo Contestant King Ruck Contestant Matti Hixson Contestant Bubba Irwin Contestant Scott Marshall Contestant Melissa Monroe Contestant Roland Pacheco Contestant Randy Vollink Contestant Charlie Corwin Executive Producer Andrea Richter Executive Producer