Dave Navarro Host Chris Nunez Judge Oliver Peck Judge Angel Contestant Julia Carlson Contestant LT Contestant Jason Clay Dunn Contestant Emily Elegado Contestant Cris Element Contestant Ryan Eternal Contestant Caroline Evans Contestant Tim Lees Contestant Aaron Is Contestant Cleen Rock One Contestant Don Peddicord Contestant Robbie Ripoll Contestant Jayvo Scott Contestant Erik Siuda Contestant Ty'Esha Reels Contestant Mark Longenecker Contestant Charlie Corwin Executive Producer Andrea Richter Executive Producer