Dave Navarro Host Chris Nunez Judge Oliver Peck Judge Anwon "Boneface" Johnson Contestant Carolyn Elaine Contestant Dave Robinowitz Actor Geary Morrill Actor Eric Gonzalez Actor Gia Rose Actor Gian Karle Cruze Actor John Collins Actor Kelly Doty Actor Kevin Laroy Actor Matt Murray Actor Mike McAskill Actor Nate Beavers Actor Ryan Ashley Actor Sirvone Smith Actor Sketchy Lawyer Actor Tito "Tuff Tito" Velez Actor Andrea Richter Executive Producer Steven Weinstock Executive Producer Glenda Hersh Executive Producer Paul Starkman Director