Dave Navarro Host Chris Nunez Judge Oliver Peck Judge Anwon "Boneface" Johnson Contestant Carolyn Elaine Contestant Dave Robinowitz Contestant Eric Gonzalez Contestant Geary Morrill Contestant Gia Rose Contestant Gian Karle Cruze Contestant John Collins Contestant Kelly Doty Contestant Kevin Laroy Contestant Matt Murray Contestant Mike McAskill Contestant Nate Beavers Contestant Nikki Simpson Contestant Ryan Ashley Contestant Sirvone Smith Contestant Sketchy Lawyer Contestant Tito "Tuff Tito" Velez Contestant Andrea Richter Executive Producer Steven Weinstock Executive Producer Glenda Hersh Executive Producer